I personally think Susie died in the same night as Charlie since I believe the Puppet minigame and Fruity Maze happen at the same time.

(I fucking hate the FNaF lore, holy fucking shit)
William drives in a drunken state after killing Henry's daughter due to his envy and hatred for him. Good ol' Will gets out of the crime scene and recklessly speeds his way back to home but accidentally does an oopsie by running over Susie's dog along the way. Since he is drunk and is unable to think straight, he lashes out on her and her family since he thinks they're the reason he did roadkill. The man thought he'd take this as an opportunity to follow Susie's family to Freddy's, and kill her for shits and giggles. Also her dog ruined his car.

Charlie dies at Fredbear's Family Diner while Susie dies in Freddy Fazbear's Pizza, the original location for the Withered animatronics. (Shoutout to, Julia BP for informing me.)

Original Meme:
lucifossi (Video privated)

Audio Used:
youtu.be/8xWhVn5Ny38

Current Sub Count: 23k

Sunny's AU Funfact: Susie favors cheese pizza. Her older sibling, Cassidy can't say the same. They prefer pineapple pizza.

• Pick A Flower Meme | FNaF GC ( Download)
• Sing or I'll shoot!!! || Ft: Past Afton Family & Glitchtrap And... Vincent [Read the description]. ( Download)
• Aftons react to Dad i can explain... @planetariumgroup657 ( Download)
• ⋆.ೃ࿔*:･🍰|| A Gassy Living Room //Gacha Fart ||🍰⋆.ೃ࿔*:･Angie9x10 ( Download)